Dovetail vs. ATLAS.ti | Best Qualitative Data Analysis Software

Thinking about Dovetail for analyzing your qualitative data? Look at the key differences between ATLAS.ti and Dovetail to see why ATLAS.ti is the superior solution for qualitative researchers.

Last updated
July 2, 2024
Dovetail
ATLAS.ti
Dovetail
ATLAS.ti
AI-powered Data Analysis
AI Summaries
AI Suggested Codes
AI-powered coding
Conversational AI
Intentional AI Coding
Paper Search capabilities
Free access to 200M+ papers through Paper Search 2.0
Streamlined literature search
Advanced filters for relevant papers
Tailored AI summaries of top papers
Full integration with research projects
Auto-Coding Tools
Sentiment Analysis
Focus Group Coding
Concepts Tool
Opinion Mining
Named Entity Recognition
Visualizations
Treemaps
Bar charts
Networks
Code clouds
Force-directed graphs
Sankey diagrams
Compatible Social Media Data
Twitter/X
YouTube
Facebook
Instagram
TikTok
Compatible Text Files
Microsoft Word
Plain text
PDF files
Rich text files
Open Office
HTML files
Open Office XML
Other Compatible Files
Video files
Audio files
Images
Geographical data
MOBI eBook files
Support
Technical support
Methodological guidance
Project optimization
24/5 support via telephone, email, and live chat
Miscellaneous
Unlimited access to all software features and platforms with a single license
Real-time, online collaboration
Project sharing
Code-code and code-document analyses
Memos Simple memoing capabilities Full flexibility to link memos to all project entities
Networks Limited layout options Automatic layout options and customizable links
Rich data retrieval capabilities Limited capabilities in retrieving tags Simple interface for intricate data retrieval in Query Tool
Text analysis Simple text retrieval tools Full analysis capabilities in Text Search, Word Frequencies, and Concepts
Dovetail
AI-powered Data Analysis
AI Summaries
AI Suggested Codes
AI-powered coding
Conversational AI
Intentional AI Coding
Paper Search capabilities
Free access to 200M+ papers through Paper Search 2.0
Streamlined literature search
Advanced filters for relevant papers
Tailored AI summaries of top papers
Full integration with research projects
Auto-Coding Tools
Sentiment Analysis
Focus Group Coding
Concepts Tool
Opinion Mining
Named Entity Recognition
Visualizations
Treemaps
Bar charts
Networks
Code clouds
Force-directed graphs
Sankey diagrams
Compatible Social Media Data
Twitter/X
YouTube
Facebook
Instagram
TikTok
Compatible Text Files
Microsoft Word
Plain text
PDF files
Rich text files
Open Office
HTML files
Open Office XML
Other Compatible Files
Video files
Audio files
Images
Geographical data
MOBI eBook files
Support
Technical support
Methodological guidance
Project optimization
24/5 support via telephone, email, and live chat
Miscellaneous
Unlimited access to all software features and platforms with a single license
Real-time, online collaboration
Project sharing
Code-code and code-document analyses
Memos
Simple memoing capabilities
Networks
Limited layout options
Rich data retrieval capabilities
Limited capabilities in retrieving tags
Text analysis
Simple text retrieval tools
ATLAS.ti
AI-powered Data Analysis
AI Summaries
AI Suggested Codes
AI-powered coding
Conversational AI
Intentional AI Coding
Paper Search capabilities
Free access to 200M+ papers through Paper Search 2.0
Streamlined literature search
Advanced filters for relevant papers
Tailored AI summaries of top papers
Full integration with research projects
Auto-Coding Tools
Sentiment Analysis
Focus Group Coding
Concepts Tool
Opinion Mining
Named Entity Recognition
Visualizations
Treemaps
Bar charts
Networks
Code clouds
Force-directed graphs
Sankey diagrams
Compatible Social Media Data
Twitter/X
YouTube
Facebook
Instagram
TikTok
Compatible Text Files
Microsoft Word
Plain text
PDF files
Rich text files
Open Office
HTML files
Open Office XML
Other Compatible Files
Video files
Audio files
Images
Geographical data
MOBI eBook files
Support
Technical support
Methodological guidance
Project optimization
24/5 support via telephone, email, and live chat
Miscellaneous
Unlimited access to all software features and platforms with a single license
Real-time, online collaboration
Project sharing
Code-code and code-document analyses
Memos
Full flexibility to link memos to all project entities
Networks
Automatic layout options and customizable links
Rich data retrieval capabilities
Simple interface for intricate data retrieval in Query Tool
Text analysis
Full analysis capabilities in Text Search, Word Frequencies, and Concepts

Important considerations for analyzing qualitative data

What goes into the decision-making process of choosing the right qualitative data analysis software? Researchers have many choices and many different needs, so let's explore what to look out for.

Ease of learning and accessibility

A QDA platform should be accessible to both novice and experienced researchers. An easy-to-learn software with a gentle learning curve reduces the time spent on training and allows researchers to focus on analysis rather than troubleshooting. Platforms that offer intuitive interfaces and user-friendly features help in streamlining the research process, making it easier for researchers to manage their projects efficiently, regardless of their prior experience with qualitative data analysis software.

Integration with research methodologies

The effectiveness of a QDA platform is measured by how well it integrates with all kinds of research, including academic research, market research, and user research. Researchers should seek software that supports diverse analytical approaches, whether grounded theory, content analysis, or discourse analysis. A flexible QDA platform allows customization to fit the unique needs of each study, ensuring that the software adapts to the researcher’s methodological framework rather than the other way around, enabling more meaningful and precise data analysis.

Advanced analysis features

For in-depth qualitative research, advanced analysis features are essential. A QDA platform should provide tools that go beyond basic coding, such as pattern recognition, theme development, and complex queries. These features enable researchers to uncover deeper insights from their data. The availability of automated coding, sentiment analysis, and other AI-powered tools further enhances the analysis, allowing researchers to focus on interpreting the results rather than getting bogged down by manual processes.

Customizable visual representation

Effective qualitative research requires clear communication of findings, often through visual means. A QDA platform that offers customizable visualizations, such as network diagrams, concept maps, and word clouds, helps researchers present their data in a compelling and accessible way. The ability to tailor these visuals to specific research needs ensures that the key insights are highlighted and understood, facilitating the dissemination of research findings to a broader audience.

Flexibility in data types and sources

Qualitative researchers can employ many forms of data collection, including methods that collect unstructured data such as text, audio, video, and social media content. A robust QDA platform should accommodate these diverse data types seamlessly, enabling comprehensive analysis. The ability to import, organize, and analyze different forms of data within a single platform is crucial, as it ensures that researchers can integrate all relevant materials into their analysis, providing a more holistic understanding of the research subject.

Continuous updates and support

The landscape of qualitative research is continually evolving, and so should the tools that support it. Researchers should look for QDA platforms that offer regular updates to incorporate new features, improve user experience, and adapt to emerging research needs. Alongside updates, a strong support network—comprising technical assistance, training resources, and methodological guidance—ensures that researchers can fully leverage the platform’s capabilities, leading to more effective and impactful research outcomes.

Comparing Dovetail vs. ATLASti

Dovetail and ATLAS.ti can both handle and analyze qualitative data, but what sets ATLAS.ti apart? Here are some of the key features where ATLAS.ti excels at qualitative data analysis over Dovetail.

  1. Coding and Tagging Capabilities
  2. Literature Review and Research Integration
  3. Automated Coding Tools
  4. Data Analysis Flexibility
  5. Visualizations and Reporting
  6. Memoing and Theoretical Insights
  7. User Interface and Usability
  8. Data Organization and Management
  9. Teamwork and Collaboration
  10. Data Types and Compatibility
  11. Survey Analysis Tools
  12. Support and Training

Coding and Tagging Capabilities

When comparing ATLAS.ti and Dovetail in terms of data coding capabilities, ATLAS.ti is both flexible and powerful. ATLAS.ti offers a robust manual coding process that allows users to highlight and code text seamlessly, with options to apply codes quickly through features like Quick Coding and Code In Vivo. This facilitates the creation of a detailed and organized coding structure, which is essential for rigorous qualitative analysis. Additionally, ATLAS.ti's support for hierarchical coding and sub-coding enables researchers to develop complex and nuanced coding schemes tailored to their research questions. Dovetail, while user-friendly and efficient for tagging, lacks the same level of granularity and flexibility. Its tagging system is more suited for surface-level categorization and lacks the depth required for more comprehensive qualitative analysis. Moreover, ATLAS.ti's integration with AI-driven coding tools further enhances its capabilities, allowing for automated coding that can be tailored to specific research inquiries. This gives ATLAS.ti a significant edge in handling complex data sets and generating meaningful insights. In contrast, Dovetail's tagging tools are more limited, making ATLAS.ti the preferred choice for researchers needing advanced coding functionalities.

Coding is powerful and organized in ATLAS.ti.

Literature Review and Research Integration

When it comes to literature review and research integration, ATLAS.ti offers advanced features that help researchers conduct research at every stage of the process. ATLAS.ti allows seamless integration of reference manager data from programs like Zotero and EndNote, facilitating the incorporation of your research library into your qualitative analysis. Moreover, ATLAS.ti Web's unique Paper Search tool enables users to search over 200 million journal articles directly within the platform, significantly enhancing the literature review process. This feature, combined with tailored AI Summaries to answer questions about the literature, helps researchers efficiently build a comprehensive library of relevant literature, which directly informs their data analysis. On the other hand, Dovetail lacks such an integrated approach, making it more challenging to align literature reviews with ongoing data analysis. While Dovetail provides basic options for tagging research materials, it doesn't offer the same depth of integration or the ability to conduct literature searches within the platform itself. This makes ATLAS.ti a more powerful tool for researchers who need to connect their literature reviews directly with their data analysis, streamlining the research process and ensuring that all relevant information is easily accessible within a single environment.

Integrated tools like Paper Search make ATLAS.ti suitable for every stage in a research project.

Automated Coding Tools

ATLAS.ti's AI-powered and automated coding tools offer a comprehensive and customizable approach to qualitative data processing, giving it a significant advantage over Dovetail. ATLAS.ti allows researchers to utilize artificial intelligence to automate coding based on specific research questions and objectives. This flexibility in AI-driven coding helps in organizing complex data sets into meaningful categories, facilitating deeper analysis. Dovetail, while incorporating AI in some features, provides only basic summaries of data without auto-coding capabilities. On the other hand, ATLAS.ti's AI-powered tools such as Conversational AI, AI Suggested Codes and Intentional AI Coding can identify core insights in your data and help you auto-code key segments of data quickly and easily. Additionally, ATLAS.ti's Conversational AI tool enhances data synthesis across multiple documents, enabling researchers to explore overarching themes and trends effectively. ATLAS.ti’s robust AI-powered tools ensure that researchers can conduct detailed and nuanced analysis with greater efficiency, making it the preferred choice for complex research projects. Additionally, ATLAS.ti's automation extends to Sentiment Analysis, Opinion Mining, Text Search, Concepts, Word Frequencies, and Named Entity Recognition, providing a comprehensive suite of tools that support thorough and valuable data analysis. This makes ATLAS.ti the preferred choice for researchers seeking to leverage automation for richer and more precise insights, ensuring that their analysis is both efficient and comprehensive.

Intentional AI Coding is one of many tools in ATLAS.ti that facilitate automated coding of qualitative data.

Data Analysis Flexibility

ATLAS.ti offers flexible and robust data analysis capabilities, enabling researchers to adapt the platform to various research needs. With its advanced Query Tool, users can create complex queries using Boolean operators, proximity searches, and other criteria, allowing for detailed exploration of coded data. This tool streamlines the analysis process by accommodating multiple criteria in a single query, something that often requires several steps in other platforms like Dovetail. Moreover, ATLAS.ti’s interface allows seamless integration of different analysis tools, such as Code Co-Occurrence and Code-Document Analysis, within a unified workspace. This integration enables researchers to quickly cross-examine data from multiple angles and create visualizations that capture the relationships between codes and documents. In contrast, Dovetail provides a more linear approach to data analysis, which may limit researchers who need to perform complex, multi-faceted analyses. ATLAS.ti’s ability to handle intricate data analysis tasks while remaining user-friendly makes it the superior choice for researchers seeking both depth and efficiency in their qualitative research.

Code Co-Occurrence Analysis enables generation of valuable insights from coded qualitative data.

Visualizations and Reporting

ATLAS.ti provides more pathways to visualizations and reporting than Dovetail, offering a range of tools that transform complex qualitative data into clear, impactful visuals. The platform provides advanced data visualization capabilities like Sankey diagrams, force-directed graphs, and treemaps, allowing researchers to illustrate code distributions and themes comprehensively. These visualizations are fully integrated with the coding and analysis process, making it easy to transition from data exploration to creating visuals that support research findings. Dovetail has basic visualizations like bar charts, Treemaps, and pie charts, all found in ATLAS.ti. However, for illustrating more complex relationships and patterns within data to highlight critical insights, ATLAS.ti's capabilities for creating Sankey diagrams, force-directed graphs, and word clouds provide more options for persuasive research. Additionally, ATLAS.ti's Network View allows users to create conceptual maps that link codes, quotations, and memos, offering a visual representation of theoretical frameworks. This makes it easier for researchers to communicate their insights and findings effectively. In contrast, Dovetail's reporting tools are more limited, making ATLAS.ti the preferred choice for researchers who need to produce detailed, high-quality reports and visuals that convey the richness of their qualitative data.

Networks in ATLAS.ti make it easy to visualize the key features of your data analysis.

Memoing and Theoretical Insights

ATLAS.ti's memoing capabilities offer a robust platform for developing theoretical insights, making it an essential tool for qualitative researchers. Memos in ATLAS.ti are highly flexible, allowing researchers to link them directly to specific quotations, codes, documents, or groups. This seamless integration enables researchers to capture and organize their thoughts, reflections, and theoretical developments as they arise during data analysis. Unlike Dovetail with its text-based memos, ATLAS.ti provides a dynamic environment where memos can be linked to data or stand alone, facilitating deeper connections between data and theory. Additionally, ATLAS.ti supports various types of memos, such as analytical, methodological, and theoretical memos, giving researchers the freedom to explore different aspects of their research systematically. This feature is particularly valuable for developing and refining theoretical frameworks, as it allows researchers to track their evolving understanding of the data throughout the research process. In contrast, Dovetail’s memoing tools are more limited, making ATLAS.ti the superior choice for researchers who need a comprehensive platform for generating and organizing theoretical insights.

Qualitative data analysis documented in research memos promotes more robust research.

User Interface and Usability

ATLAS.ti's user interface is designed with usability in mind, offering a clean and organized layout that enhances the qualitative research experience. The interface allows users to easily navigate between different project components, such as documents, codes, and memos, within a single window, minimizing clutter and improving workflow efficiency. The centralization of tools under easily accessible menus ensures that researchers can quickly find and use the features they need. In contrast, Dovetail’s interface, while user-friendly, lacks the same level of integration and customization options, which can limit its effectiveness for more complex projects. ATLAS.ti's streamlined design supports both novice and experienced users, making it a versatile choice for qualitative data analysis.

ATLAS.ti's versatile interface is ideal for annotating data in all qualitative research projects.

Data Organization and Management

ATLAS.ti provides powerful data organization and management, offering tools that allow researchers to categorize and sort data with exceptional flexibility. The platform’s Document Manager enables users to group documents by multiple categories, such as data types, data sources, data collection methods such as interviews or focus groups, or participant demographics, without being restricted by a rigid file structure. Moreover, project data can be exported as spreadsheets for statistical analysis in other programs for greater flexibility. This allows for a more nuanced organization that supports complex analysis from various perspectives. In contrast, Dovetail offers a more straightforward approach with a simple interface for data management, which may suffice for smaller projects but lacks the sophistication needed for extensive qualitative research. ATLAS.ti's ability to handle large, multifaceted projects makes it the preferred choice for researchers who require detailed and dynamic data organization.

The Document Manager in ATLAS.ti helps researchers organize all forms of data collection.

Teamwork and Collaboration

ATLAS.ti offers robust collaboration and teamwork features that are essential for qualitative research projects involving multiple team members. The platform supports real-time collaboration through ATLAS.ti Web, allowing team members to code and analyze data simultaneously, regardless of their location. This feature is complemented by cloud storage for ATLAS.ti Mac and Windows, which facilitates easy project sharing, data management, and tools for intercoder agreement. Unlike in Dovetail, ATLAS.ti can help researchers analyze the level of agreement among research team members in terms of coding. Overall, ATLAS.ti's ability to support unlimited team members and seamless project sharing makes it the superior choice for collaborative research.

ATLAS.ti Web provides intuitive real-time collaboration tools for coding research data.

Data Types and Compatibility

ATLAS.ti offers superior compatibility with a wide range of data types, making it highly versatile for qualitative research. The platform supports various file formats, including text, PDF, images, audio, video, and even geographic data, allowing researchers to incorporate diverse sources into their projects. This flexibility extends to handling complex data types, such as comments in PDFs or multimedia files, which can be directly integrated into the analysis. In contrast, Dovetail’s compatibility is limited to text, video, and audio files, which can constrain researchers working with diverse datasets such as eBooks and geographic data. ATLAS.ti’s broad compatibility ensures that researchers can manage and analyze all relevant data within a single, cohesive platform, making it an ideal choice for projects that require comprehensive data integration.

ATLAS.ti supports analysis of various types of data, including multimedia files.

Survey Analysis Tools

When it comes to survey analysis, ATLAS.ti offers a powerful suite of tools that cater to both qualitative and mixed-methods research. Researchers can import survey data directly into the platform and apply coding to open-ended responses, enabling them to identify patterns and themes with precision. ATLAS.ti's automated tools, such as AI Coding and Sentiment Analysis, further enhance the analysis by quickly categorizing responses and identifying actionable insights. While Dovetail is capable of handling basic survey data, ATLAS.ti’s ability to seamlessly integrate survey data with other qualitative data types makes it the ideal choice for researchers looking to conduct comprehensive survey analyses, offering detailed insights that are critical for data-driven decision-making.

Survey records like customer data and market feedback are easy to collect and analyze in ATLAS.ti.

Support and Training

More than the software itself, ATLAS.ti provides greater support to ensure qualitative researchers have all the resources they need to make data-driven decisions through their research. While Dovetail provides support only through email and has limited online resources like webinars and sample projects to guide researchers, ATLAS.ti users enjoy more options to assist them with every step of the research process. For all questions and issues great and small, from technical support to methodological guidance, ATLAS.ti provides live support via telephone, email, and chat, 24 hours a day, five days a week. This perpetual support complements ATLAS.ti's extensive resources and live webinars on qualitative research methods and data analysis available for free, ensuring that you have everything you need to analyze your data and generate valuable insights from your research.

ATLAS.ti's live support and extensive resources are available to help researchers conduct research.